Our rules

The rules that make this a club, not a comment section.

Read these before you join. Every member agrees to them, moderators enforce them, and we'd rather lose a member than bend one.

  1. 01
    Public records only

    Everything we work from is a document anyone can request: FOIA responses, court files, property and transit records, archived news. If you can't source it, it doesn't go in.

  2. 02
    No contact. With anyone.

    Never reach out to a family, a witness, a suspect, or their employer, neighbour, or child — online or off. Not to be helpful. Not once.

  3. 03
    No naming un-charged people

    We don't publish, post, or say aloud the name of anyone who hasn't been charged. No initials, no hints, no 'everyone knows who I mean'.

  4. 04
    No doxxing

    No addresses, workplaces, phone numbers, or family details of any private individual. This one gets you removed immediately, first offence.

  5. 05
    Agencies come first

    If law enforcement asks us to pause or drop a case, we do it that day — and members don't continue on their own under the club's name.

  6. 06
    Speak carefully about victims

    Write about people the way you'd want a stranger to write about your family. Speculation about a victim's choices isn't investigation.

Seen something that breaks these rules, inside the club or out? Tell a moderator. We take it seriously and we'll tell you what we did about it.